St. Patrick’s Day “Luck of the Irish” Homemade Oreos



So I have a confession; I am not Irish. Not even close to being Irish.

The closest I get is that I like beer and boys with Irish accents.  Soooo basically I’m American. And 25 years old.


But we all know that the whole ‘not being remotely related to this holiday’ thing would never stand in my way. Give me green. A couple sticks of butter. And let me get to work!



I knew I wanted something simple and easy – because when you’re baking cookies for your kid’s class party, office friends, or holiday get together; you want to look like Martha Stewart but cook like Betty Crocker. The cookies and the frosting whip up pretty quick, the only extra step is using cookie cutters right when the cookies come out of the oven and piping the frosting. Pretty pretty easy guys!


If you don’t have alphabet cookie cutters  you can definitely leave that step out! Green oreos are just as festive :) Plus you can switch up the colors and tailor these to whatever holiday you want… pink for Easter.. red white & blue for the 4th… I only found half the alphabet hiding in my horribly disorganized baking cabinet – so voila! Spelled “Lucky” using a rotated “U” for the “C”.


Happy St. Patty’s Day everyone!! 


Recipe Adapted from Martha Stewart



  1. I don’t get very excited for St. Patrick’s Day. I will get excited for these cookies. Cute, cute, cute!

  2. I love how festive your cookies are. I still need to try making my own homemade Oreos. I will have to bookmark these!

  3. Too cute! I love the cut-out letters on top…I am totally using that idea for birthday cookies down the line!

  4. I love the letter cookie cutter idea! That’s awesome! And not to mention the homemade oreo’s :p

  5. Kristina these are seriously adorable – omg I love the cookie cutter “lucky” and who doesn’t jump up and down at the thought of homemade oreos?!? :D

  6. These are SO gorgeous!!! LOVE the green, and the letters!

  7. OMG these are amazing my sweet! I so wish that I could be eating sweets now. Lent is almost over though. YUM!

  8. OMG these are the most adorable cookies ever! And oreos are so amazing to beging with.

  9. Girl you can take the Irish-ness, I so don’t want it! Lol

    Bit omg these cookies! I love them! They look yummy and cute as all get out!

  10. If I had a blender, these would be the official St. Patrick’s Day cookies in Ireland this year. Great job Kristina. Maybe I can convince my neighbors to lend me theirs?

    • Whipped Baking says:

      Haha yes! You need to make friends with all the neighborhood old ladies asap.

  11. It’s a green recipe that isn’t mint! Yay!!!

    Also, I nominated you for the Versatile Blogger Award.

  12. I love oreos and i`m love the st. patty`s day flare. hehe. :)

  13. Emily LeDonne says:

    Would it taste weird if I use whole wheat pastry flour? I love this recipe but I dont have enough all purpose!

    • Whipped Baking says:

      They’ll definitely be a bit different tasting, more earthier and a lot denser. I don’t usually recommend using only whole wheat flour in a recipe because sometimes it can make baked goods too heavy, but it’s always good to experiment! There’s a lot of chocolate in this recipe to cover up the whole wheat flavor so this might be an instance where it works :)


  1. […] and creative cook who mixes lovely healthy recipes with yummy desserts. My favorites include Homemade Oreos, Butternut Squash Salad with Maple Vinaigrette, Turkey Sloppy Joes, and Spicy Shrimp and Avocado […]